<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=256579306243461&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

The most trustworthy sites to purchase jewelry from

Person shopping for jewelry online

While perusing the internet for a sparkly new necklace, bracelet, or ring is fun to do, ordering online can be stressful. After all, without seeing the piece in person, how can you be certain you’ll be satisfied with the product that arrives on your doorstep? And even more importantly, how can you be sure it’s made with the materials you think it is? Jewelry is often expensive, and it’s important to make sure you get what you pay for. This is why it’s so important to shop with a company you can trust.

With so much left to chance when buying jewelry online, you want to make sure you're protected in case anything goes wrong. Mulberry Unlimited lets you get coverage for all your jewelry pieces under the same product protection plan. For a low monthly price, you get unlimited claims and coverage, with no deductibles or hidden fees. It's perfect for protecting what's nearest and dearest to you.

Protect unlimited online purchases for $9.99/month

What are trustworthy sites to purchase jewelry from?

Check out our list of the most reliable online jewelry retailers below:

Mejuri Jewelry

Mejuri is a trusted name in the online jewelry world. From bracelets to charms, earrings, and necklaces, Mejuri jewelry is crafted from high-quality materials that are built to last a lifetime. Mejuri offers free shipping for US customers on purchases over $75, as well as free returns within 30 days.

On another note, if you’re looking for an environmentally-friendly option, you’re in luck: Many Mejuri jewelry pieces are made from recycled materials, so you can feel good about your purchase.


Looking for a fun, trendy new jewelry piece but hoping not to break the bank? Baublebar is one of the best online retailers for affordable jewelry. From custom bracelets to ear cuffs, rings, and much more, Baublebar offers all types of jewelry for a price that’s hard to beat.

Looking for a fun gift for a friend, daughter or sister? Try a snazzy pair of Baublebar earrings. Most of Baublebar’s earrings are $50 or less, making them an excellent, budget-friendly option to give as a gift or keep for yourself.

Catbird Jewelry

Searching for a special gift for a special someone? Or maybe just a fun new piece for yourself? Catbird Jewelry’s high-quality materials, sleek and trendy pieces, and ethical business practices are hard to beat. Whether you’re looking for an inexpensive bracelet or you’re ready to splurge on an investment piece, Catbird Jewelry has it all.

Bonus: for most purchases in the United States, shipping and returns are only $5 each (and yes, returns are accepted with no strings attached as long as they take place within 10 days of the original purchase date).

Gorjana Jewelry

Classy and timeless pieces sold for an affordable price–if these are your priorities when shopping for jewelry, Gorjana Jewelry is a great place to start. Whether you’re looking for a minimalist chain or a glitzy diamond studded ring, Gorjana offers stunning pieces for incredible prices.

On top of that, Gorjana Jewelry offers free shipping and returns on every purchase, so you can order as many pieces as you want to try without fear that you won’t like them. With Gorjana Jewelry, shopping online for a new piece is painless and simple.


Is there any name in the world of online fashion that’s more trusted than Nordstrom? From designer coats to children’s pajamas, Nordstrom has it all–including jewelry. Whether you’re looking for a new pair of statement hoop earrings, a set of bangle bracelets, or a hefty, 18-karat gold ring, you’re sure to find exactly what you’re looking for at Nordstrom.

Another benefit of shopping at Nordstrom is their numerous brick-and-mortar locations across the United States, which allow you to order online and pick up in store if you’d like. Not close to a Nordstrom store? Don’t worry–you’ll get free delivery and free returns with almost any online purchase, making the online shopping process easy, quick, and painless.

Final thoughts

Whether you opt for a sparkly pair of Baublebar earrings or drop several hundred dollars on a new David Yurman ring from Nordstrom, when you know where to look, shopping online for jewelry is fun, easy, and just as risk-free as visiting the store.

And when shopping for your new jewelry, don’t forget to think about product protection. While some jewelry pieces are affordable, many are investment pieces that you hope will last for years to come, and there’s nothing worse than losing money on an expensive purchase! Purchasing a product protection plan is the best way to make sure that you get your money’s worth out of your purchase. Subscribe to Mulberry Unlimited to get the most complete coverage on all your products!

  • Share
Kim Miller

About the author

Kim Miller is the Head of Consumer Marketing at Mulberry. She is passionate about building products and brands that make consumers happy, save them money and make their lives easier. Have an innovative idea for Mulberry you'd like to share? Give her a shout! She'd love to chat about anything from fintech and UX to gardening and antiquing.

You also might like:

Subscribe for the latest articles